The US Used to Demand the Best Tech. Now We Ban It
The US has shifted from demanding the best technology globally to banning foreign tech, especially from China, citing security concerns. The author criticizes this protectionist approach, exemplified by actions against TikTok and Huawei, as harmful to American competitiveness and innovation.
Background
- The author contrasts the US' historical approach to technology (embracing innovation, exemplified by building the transcontinental railroad using the best available steel) with its current trend toward banning products like TikTok and certain AI models.
- The shift reflects growing US-China tech rivalry; government restrictions target Chinese-owned apps (TikTok, WeChat) and advanced semiconductor exports to China, driven by national security and data privacy fears.
- "Best tech" refers to the US once prioritizing performance and efficiency; critics argue bans signal protectionism or fear of competition rather than a commitment to technical excellence or free markets.
- The piece belongs to a broader debate about whether security concerns justify limiting consumer choice and stalling global tech development.