Translation

Ask HN: Do pull requests have value?

A Hacker News discussion thread explores whether human-reviewed pull requests provide value in corporate development environments, with commenters debating their effectiveness for code quality, collaboration, and process overhead.

Background

- A **pull request (PR)** is a developer's proposed code change submitted for review by teammates before it is merged into the main project. The practice is standard in companies using Git-based platforms like GitHub, GitLab, or Bitbucket. - The poster is asking whether human code review (reading and commenting on each other's PRs) is genuinely useful in a corporate setting, or whether it has become a bureaucratic checkbox that slows teams down without catching real bugs. - This sits inside a long-running debate in software engineering: proponents argue PRs catch mistakes, spread knowledge, and enforce quality standards; critics say they create delays, encourage shallow reviewing, and that pairing or automated testing would be more effective. - The question resonates especially now because many developers suspect PR review has become performative — "looks good to me" rubber-stamping — rather than a meaningful quality gate.

RT Max Weinbach: I had early access to this model and I'll post more Thursday, but I think the most impressive part is this model NEVER GIVES UP If yo...
9.0
Max Weinbach says he had early access to OpenAI's new model GPT-5.6 Sol, calling it his favorite model by far. He highlights that it never gives up and will keep reasoning until it's done. OpenAI announced that GPT-5.6 Sol, along with Terra and Luna, will launch publicly on Thursday, with preview access expanding globally now.
Statement on the US government directive to suspend access to Fable 5 and Mythos 5
9.0
The US government ordered Anthropic to suspend access to its Fable 5 and Mythos 5 models for all customers, citing a potential jailbreak technique that involved asking the model to review a codebase for vulnerabilities—a capability Anthropic says is available in other public models. Access was abruptly cut off on June 12.
This is a super exciting release - Claude Fable 5 is the same underlying model as Mythos but with added safeguards. The benchmarks are great and it's ...
9.0
Andrej Karpathy announces the release of Claude Fable 5, the same underlying model as Mythos but with added safeguards. He calls it a major step forward, particularly for long problem-solving sessions on difficult tasks, and describes it as state-of-the-art on nearly all benchmarks with exceptional performance in software engineering, research, and vision.
RT Roman Storm 🇺🇸 🌪️: The gov't theory in my case isn't about me. It's a template. Under US v. Storm, "money transmitting" no longer require...
8.5
Roman Storm warns that the legal theory in his case could set a precedent making open-source developers liable for how others use their code, potentially criminalizing the mere publication of privacy, messaging, or crypto tools. He notes that developer Michael Lewellen cannot publish lawful code due to prosecution fears, and argues this chilling effect extends beyond any single case.
‘Why Is Meta Destroying Its Engineering Organization?’
8.5
Meta's engineering culture is deteriorating under Mark Zuckerberg and Scale AI CEO Alexandr Wang, who have introduced keyboard tracking, reassignments to data labeling, and AI-centric performance metrics. Critics argue this incentivizes performative AI use, drives away experienced engineers, and contributed to a major Instagram hijacking incident caused by AI-written and AI-reviewed code.

Ask HN: Do pull requests have value?

Background

Related stories

RT Max Weinbach: I had early access to this model and I'll post more Thursday, but I think the most impressive part is this model NEVER GIVES UP If yo...

Statement on the US government directive to suspend access to Fable 5 and Mythos 5

This is a super exciting release - Claude Fable 5 is the same underlying model as Mythos but with added safeguards. The benchmarks are great and it's ...

RT Roman Storm 🇺🇸 🌪️: The gov't theory in my case isn't about me. It's a template. Under US v. Storm, "money transmitting" no longer require...

‘Why Is Meta Destroying Its Engineering Organization?’