NYT calls University of California 'test-blind' admissions a 'terrible' mistake
The New York Times editorial board criticized the University of California's 'test-blind' admissions policy, calling it a 'terrible mistake' that eliminates standardized test scores from consideration. The board argued the policy may hurt efforts to increase diversity and could disadvantage disadvantaged students by removing a tool that helps identify talent across different backgrounds.
Background
- Since 2021, the University of California (UC) system has been "test-blind" — it does not consider SAT or ACT scores at all in admissions, even if applicants submit them. This goes further than "test-optional" policies used by many colleges.
- A recent New York Times essay (by two education researchers) argues that dropping standardized tests has made UC admissions less fair. They claim it harms high-achieving students from less privileged backgrounds, who could have used strong scores to stand out in a pool where grades alone are less differentiating.
- Critics of standardized tests say they favor wealthy students who can afford test prep and reflect systemic biases. Supporters argue the tests are a useful, objective benchmark when grades from different high schools are hard to compare.
- The UC system's move was driven by equity concerns and political pressure. California's debate over test-blind admissions has national significance because UC is one of the largest and most prestigious public university systems in the U.S.