Another annoying thing about getting emails people have used AIs to write for them is that they're usually longer than they'd have written by themselv...
Paul Graham complains that emails written with AI assistance tend to be overly long, filled with paragraphs of plausible-sounding but unnecessary text, unlike the more concise versions people would naturally write themselves.
Background
- Paul Graham is a well-known programmer, venture capitalist, and co-founder of Y Combinator (the influential Silicon Valley startup accelerator). He regularly writes essays on technology and startup culture, and his tweets often get wide attention in tech circles.
- This tweet reflects a growing frustration in professional settings as large language models (like ChatGPT) become common tools for drafting emails. Critics argue that AI-generated writing tends to produce longer, more verbose text that sounds plausible but lacks conciseness and personal voice.
- The complaint echoes broader debates about AI writing: it often fills space with generic filler, obscures intent, and forces recipients to wade through more text to extract the same information. Graham's point is that AI assistance, in this case, worsens communication rather than improving it.
ccMarvin is a new AI service accessible via email at marvin@ccmarvin.com. It functions as a research assistant that can track private or public investments from news sources and X, create custom newsletters, and send daily updates based on user commands.
The author describes frustrating arguments with fellow techies about whether it's possible to distinguish between human-written and AI-generated text, framing this as one of the most painful recurring debates in tech circles.
A Hacker News user laments the decline of genuine, human-written blogs, arguing that most articles now promote products, personal brands, or ad traffic, and that AI-generated content makes it harder to find authentic knowledge-sharing.
A Hacker News user asks how to manage an influx of AI-generated spam emails. The discussion thread seeks automated solutions for detecting and filtering these messages from inboxes.
Paul Graham says he can tell when emails from founders are written by AI, noting a hard-hitting journalistic style that didn't exist before. He states he has never finished reading an email signed by a human but written by AI, as it feels like being lied to and makes him think less of the author.