Ask HN: I miss old days of blogging without promotions
A Hacker News user laments the decline of genuine, human-written blogs, arguing that most articles now promote products, personal brands, or ad traffic, and that AI-generated content makes it harder to find authentic knowledge-sharing.
Background
- The user is posting on Hacker News ("Ask HN"), a community on Y Combinator's site where tech workers, founders, and engineers discuss software, startups, and industry trends. A post tagged "Ask HN" is a question posed to the community.
- The complaint reflects a widely felt shift in the tech blogosphere: the rise of "content marketing" (articles written to sell a product or build a personal brand) and AI-generated SEO spam, which crowd out the older, non-commercial tradition of engineers writing tutorials or sharing lessons purely for knowledge's sake.
- "Signal to noise ratio" is a common tech metaphor: useful content ("signal") is increasingly buried under low-value filler ("noise").
- The poster is nostalgic for the pre-2010s era of "indie web" blogging, when individual developers hosted their own sites and wrote without monetization motives.
The author describes frustrating arguments with fellow techies about whether it's possible to distinguish between human-written and AI-generated text, framing this as one of the most painful recurring debates in tech circles.
Paul Graham notes that many founder emails now use a hard-hitting journalistic style, which he attributes to AI because founders never wrote that way before. He observes that once an email is identified as AI-written, it's difficult not to ignore it.
Paul Graham says he can tell when emails from founders are written by AI, noting a hard-hitting journalistic style that didn't exist before. He states he has never finished reading an email signed by a human but written by AI, as it feels like being lied to and makes him think less of the author.
A tweet argues that the defining aesthetic of the current era is computer code, responding to a comment about the century lacking a distinct artistic movement. It suggests code is an invisible yet omnipresent visual and cultural force shaping modern life.
Paul Graham complains that emails written with AI assistance tend to be overly long, filled with paragraphs of plausible-sounding but unnecessary text, unlike the more concise versions people would naturally write themselves.